How to Make a Big Decision When You Are Scared
For the person stuck between two paths, replaying both, and afraid of choosing wrong.
To make a big decision when you are scared, separate what you know from what you fear, set a deadline for deciding, talk to the people it affects, and then commit and adjust as you go. Fear of choosing wrong usually costs more than choosing wrong. Most of the time people do not need more information. They need a decision.
Some of the hardest decisions I have made came with no good answer, only a choice.
During the COVID pandemic, I was working in healthcare staffing. One day I saw a skilled nursing facility in a small rural town in Iowa on the news. The executive director was speaking, and you could hear the desperation in his voice. I called and left a message.
Later that day, sitting on a bench between sets at the gym, my phone rang. It was him. Residents were sick, staff were infected, and they were running out of people. Then he asked a simple question that carried all of it: “Can you help us?”
There was not a good answer. There was just a decision. I rallied our team, because this was not about filling jobs. It was about people who were depending on us to show up.
Most of the time, people do not need more information. They need a decision.
Six steps to decide when fear is loud
Separate facts from fears
Make two columns. In one, write what you actually know. In the other, write what you are afraid might happen. Fear tends to blur the two. Seeing them apart makes the real decision smaller.
Set a deadline to decide
Endless deliberation feels responsible, but it usually just extends the stress. Pick a date. Gather what you need until then, and decide on that day.
Ask what you would regret
Picture yourself five years from now. Which choice would you regret not making? Regret is often a clearer guide than fear.
Talk to the people it affects
Big decisions rarely affect only you. Bring the people who will feel it into the conversation early. Their perspective sharpens the choice, and their support carries you after.
Ask what if I can handle it
Fear asks, “What if this goes wrong?” Try, “What if I can handle it?” Real security is not knowing what will happen. It is trusting yourself to handle what does.
Commit, then adjust
Most decisions are not permanent. Commit fully, then adjust as you learn. The guardrail is not perfection. It is the habit of coming back.
There was not a good answer.
There was just a decision.
When the decision affects other people
Some decisions carry weight that follows you home. I have had to make choices that affected people’s jobs and families, and I lay awake thinking about them. If that is where you are, read Carrying the Weight of Hard Decisions.
You may also find How to Take a Career Risk When You Are Scared, How to Stop Overthinking and What If I Try and It Does Not Work? helpful.
Common questions
How do I make a decision when I am scared of choosing wrong?
Separate facts from fears, set a deadline, ask which choice you would regret not making and talk to the people it affects. Then commit and adjust as you go.
Why is it so hard to make big decisions?
Big decisions carry uncertainty, and our minds treat uncertainty as danger. Overthinking feels like progress but usually just delays the choice.
How do I stop overthinking a decision?
Set a decision deadline and limit your information gathering to that window. More information rarely makes a hard choice easy.
What if I make the wrong decision?
Most decisions can be adjusted. Commit, watch what happens and course-correct. Not deciding is also a decision, often a costly one.
Separate facts from fears, set a deadline, ask what you would regret, then commit and adjust.
You Are Capable
of More.
Ten principles for becoming the person you know you are capable of being, built from real stories of people who doubted themselves and did it anyway. Winner of the How-To category at the 2026 Paris Book Festival.
When I’ve got something worth sending.
Just a story or an idea I picked up that I think will help you.
Sometimes that’s twice in a month. Sometimes it’s not for a while.