How to lead people who
used to be your peers.
The hardest promotion there is, and the one almost nobody is prepared for. Here is how to handle the first month without losing the friendships or the authority.
The short answer: name the change out loud in the first week instead of hoping everyone adjusts quietly. Have one short conversation with each person about what is different and what is not. Then be consistent, because the team is not testing whether you are still nice, they are testing whether you are fair.
The two failure modes are equal and opposite. Some new managers over-correct into distance and formality, which reads as arrogance. Others cling to being one of the crew and never make a decision anyone dislikes, which reads as weakness. The way through is not choosing between them — it is being clear about what changed and then behaving the same way with everyone.
What you have that an
outside hire does not.
This promotion is usually framed as a problem to survive. It is worth being clear about what you are actually starting with.
An outside manager spends six months learning what you already know. You can act on the real problem in week three.
Not the org chart version. You know who people actually go to, and that is information no handover document contains.
Nobody can tell you it cannot be done that way. You did the job, recently, and that is worth a great deal when you set a standard.
Trust normally takes months to establish. You start with a version of it, and your only job is not to spend it carelessly.
Six moves,
in order.
Most of this happens in week one. Delay makes every one of them harder.
Say It Out Loud in Week One
Get the team together and name the awkward thing directly. Everyone is already thinking about it, and silence lets each person invent their own version of what you are going to become.
Thirty seconds of directness here saves you two months of people reading your body language for clues.
One Conversation With Each Person
Individually, that first week. Ask what they want from you now that the relationship has changed, and say honestly what you are worried about. Two questions do most of the work.
“Is there anything about this that is going to be awkward, so we can say it now rather than in six months?”
Deal With the Person Who Wanted the Job
If someone applied and did not get it, have that conversation in the first few days. Do not wait for it to surface, and do not pretend it is not there.
Acknowledge it plainly, do not over-apologize, and ask what they want to build toward. Then actually do something about that over the next quarter. Handled well, this person often becomes your strongest ally. Handled by avoidance, they become the quiet centre of every problem you have for a year.
Change the Friendship Honestly, Not Secretly
You can still be friends with people you manage. What you cannot do is keep the parts that create unfairness: the private complaining about work, the information they get before others, the assumption of a benefit of the doubt.
Say that to your friend directly rather than quietly withdrawing. Withdrawing without explanation is what actually ends the friendship.
Be Boringly Consistent
The team is watching for one thing: whether your friends get treated differently. Not whether you are warm, whether you are fair.
The most common mistake is over-correcting by being harder on friends than on everyone else. That is just as visible and it costs you the friendship as well.
Make One Decision People Do Not Love
Sooner rather than later, and for good reasons you can explain. Until you have done this, the team does not know what kind of manager you are, and you do not either.
It does not need to be harsh. It needs to be a decision the old you would have found difficult, made and explained clearly. That is the concept underneath this whole transition.
Four situations
that come up.
What To Do When
Someone tests you publicly. Usually in a meeting, usually with a joke. Do not fight it in the room and do not laugh it off. Take it up privately the same day, specifically and briefly.
They keep coming to you for the old job. Natural, since you were the expert. Answer once, then hand it to whoever owns it now, out loud, so the team learns where the work went.
You have to give feedback to a friend. Same method as anyone else, and no softer. The six step version is here. The friendship survives honesty far better than it survives you avoiding the conversation and resenting it.
You miss being one of them. You will, and it does not mean you made a mistake. Find peers at your new level, inside the company or outside it, because that gap is the loneliest part of the job and it does not fill itself.
What their manager
should be doing.
If you run an organization that just promoted someone over their peers, most of whether this works is on you rather than on them.
Announce it properly. Say why they were chosen, specifically. A vague announcement leaves the team to invent a reason, and the reason they invent is rarely generous.
Back them visibly in the first month. One public act of support early is worth more than months of private encouragement.
Give them somewhere to be honest. They cannot talk to their team about this and they may not want to admit to you that it is hard. A cohort of other new managers solves that better than any handbook — the free new manager program is built for exactly that group.
Confidence is not built in the big moments. It is built in the promises you keep to yourself.
Common
questions.
How do you manage people who used to be your peers?
Name the change out loud in the first week rather than letting everyone guess, have one short individual conversation with each person about what is different and what is not, and then be consistent. The team is testing whether you are fair, not whether you are still friendly.
Can you stay friends with people you manage?
Yes, but not on the old terms. What has to stop is complaining about work to them, giving them information before others, and extending a benefit of the doubt you would not extend to anyone else. Say that directly rather than quietly withdrawing.
What do you do about the person who wanted your job?
Have the conversation in the first few days. Acknowledge it plainly without over-apologizing, ask what they want to build toward, and then do something about it over the next quarter. Avoidance turns that person into the centre of your problems for a year.
What if a former peer tests you in front of others?
Do not fight it in the room and do not laugh it off. Take it up privately the same day, specifically and briefly, about the behavior rather than the person.
Should you act differently after being promoted internally?
Be clear about what changed rather than changing your personality. The two failure modes are over-correcting into distance, which reads as arrogance, and clinging to being one of the crew, which reads as weakness.
How long does the awkwardness last?
Usually a few weeks if you name it early and behave consistently, and considerably longer if you wait for it to resolve on its own. Making one well-explained decision people do not love tends to end it faster than anything else.
Run it with your people.
The same ten concepts at five different levels of commitment. Every guide is written so the person running it takes part rather than instructs, and nothing is gated, licensed or paid.
The Lunch and Learn
All ten concepts at five minutes each, with a full run of show. Nobody needs to have read the book.
Open the Guide → 60 to 90 minutesThe Workshop
One concept worked properly. A question, silence, tables of four, and a commitment from every person.
Open the Guide → Ten x 45 minutesThe Book Club Guide
One session per concept, built to be run by anyone in the group. Everyone needs a copy.
Download It → One dayThe Boot Camp
All ten condensed into a day, or two half days. The group leaves with a written plan.
Open the Guide → Ten weeksThe 10-Week Program
One concept a week with real life in between. The version that changes how a group operates.
Open the Guide →Seventeen free guides for managers, sorted by the problem — first 90 days, feedback, hard conversations, retention, onboarding, meetings, retreats and change. Browse the guides, or pick the concepts your people need and get a session order back.
Choose Your SessionsSeen On
Chris has taken this material onto morning television across the country, and writes for Forbes and Inc.
When I’ve got something worth sending.
Just a story or an idea I picked up that I think will help you.
Sometimes that’s twice in a month. Sometimes it’s not for a while.