Books Like
Think Again

If you liked Think Again, the closest books are Hidden Potential by Adam Grant, Thanks for the Feedback by Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen, Superforecasting by Philip Tetlock, You Are Capable of More by Chris Sund, Being Wrong by Kathryn Schulz, and Mindset by Carol Dweck. Stone and Heen are the most useful next read, because they handle the part Grant leaves alone.

The gap Think Again leaves open

Grant makes a case that is hard to argue with. We treat our opinions like possessions, defending them because they are ours rather than because they are right, and the skill worth building is the willingness to reconsider, which he frames as thinking like a scientist rather than a preacher, a prosecutor, or a politician.

Almost everyone who reads it agrees. Almost nobody changes, and the reason is structural. Rethinking does not usually happen in a quiet moment of reflection with a book in your lap. It happens when a person you did not ask tells you something you do not want to hear, often clumsily, frequently in front of other people, and usually when you are already tired. Grant tells you to welcome that. He is thinner on how to survive it.

So the honest follow-on reading splits three ways. Either you want the practical skill of taking feedback without your defenses closing, or you want the discipline of updating beliefs against evidence, or you want the underlying psychology of what being wrong actually feels like from the inside, which is the strangest and most important of the three.

One

Thanks for the Feedback by Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen

The most useful book you can read after Think Again, and the one that fills the actual gap. Nearly every feedback book is written for the person giving it. This one is written for the person receiving it, which is the harder position and the one you occupy far more often.

Their central move is separating feedback into appreciation, coaching, and evaluation, because most bad feedback conversations are two people wanting different ones of those three. That single distinction has saved me more difficult conversations than anything else I have read.

Two

Hidden Potential by Adam Grant

Grant’s own next book, and the better of the two. Think Again is about loosening your grip on what you believe. Hidden Potential is about loosening your grip on what you believe about yourself, specifically the quiet conclusion most adults have reached that they have already found their ceiling.

It is tighter than Think Again and it lands somewhere more actionable. If you liked one you will like the other, and if you only read one more Grant book, make it this one.

Three

Superforecasting by Philip Tetlock and Dan Gardner

Tetlock spent decades demonstrating that confident experts predict the future badly, and then went looking for the ordinary people who do it well. What he found is that they update in small increments, hold beliefs loosely, and keep score on themselves.

This is Think Again with the receipts. Grant argues that rethinking is a skill. Tetlock shows you the measured performance difference between people who practice it and people who do not.

Five

Being Wrong by Kathryn Schulz

The least known book on this list and the one I most enjoyed. Schulz is a journalist, not a psychologist, and she writes about error the way a good essayist would, moving between neuroscience, philosophy, and the specific texture of moments when people discovered they had been badly wrong for years.

Her key observation is the one that makes Grant’s advice hard to follow. There is no internal sensation of being wrong. It feels precisely like being right, right up until it does not. Read it if Think Again left you wondering why the willingness never seems to be available when you need it.

Six

Mindset by Carol Dweck

Older and sitting underneath the whole category. Dweck’s finding explains why rethinking is so threatening in the first place, because if you believe ability is fixed, then being wrong is not new information, it is evidence about your worth, and no amount of encouragement to stay curious will get past that.

Read it before Think Again if you can, or after it if the willingness Grant describes keeps failing to show up.

Seven

Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman

The heaviest thing on this list and the foundation under most of the rest. Kahneman catalogs the systematic ways human judgment goes wrong, and the reading experience is unusual because you recognize yourself in nearly every bias as it is described and then commit them all again the next day.

Worth knowing that some of the priming research in the book has not replicated well, which Kahneman himself acknowledged before he died. The core work on judgment and heuristics has held up.

Which one to pick

If you want one, read Thanks for the Feedback. Think Again tells you to be open to being wrong. Stone and Heen give you something to do when it is actually happening and you would rather it were not.

Common questions